Allegations
The plaintiffs alleged failures involving consumer-report disclosure, authorization and adverse-action procedures. Allegations describe their claims; they are not findings that every alleged violation occurred.
Historical case and source standards
Start with the historical lawsuit, then explore today’s screening questions and the separate Virginia, Texas and loan-signing source trails.
Start here
Michael Anderson and other plaintiffs sued SIGNiX and the National Notary Association in the Eastern District of Virginia, Civil Action No. 3:08cv570. The historical dispute concerned consumer reports used in notary certification. Read the allegations, settlement record and present-day questions separately.
Article revision: . Historical source note: . The screening cluster's last completed source check remains July 23, 2026; September 29 was a partial review. A page revision is not a fresh check of every source.
The plaintiffs alleged failures involving consumer-report disclosure, authorization and adverse-action procedures. Allegations describe their claims; they are not findings that every alleged violation occurred.
The retained case record describes court approval of a class settlement and dismissal with prejudice. Settlement approval is not a liability verdict or, by itself, an admission of liability.
Greg's practical concern is private screening credentials influencing access to work. The old settlement establishes neither a current violation nor a compliance exemption. Today's answer depends on the actual actors, data, purpose and decision.
Read the evidence
Retained historical source note (not publicly available). This is Notary Geek's retained PACER review note, not the court documents themselves. It identifies amended complaint Doc. 3 and settlement-approval records Docs. 45, 47, 48 and 49. Precise terms below remain attributed to the retained account pending comparison with the complete original instruments.
Original-document gap: Complete originals of amended complaint Doc. 3, settlement agreement Doc. 39-1 and approval-related Docs. 45, 47, 48 and 49 remain unavailable for this review. The retained source account is not a substitute for those instruments.
15 U.S.C. § 1681a: definitions; § 1681b: permissible purposes and employment conditions; § 1681m: user duties. These links identify the 2024 U.S. Code edition, not a claim that later changes were exhaustively checked.
FTC employer guidance explains employment screening. Its employment examples do not settle every independent-contractor relationship. These four sources were checked through public text retrieval on October 26, 2026.
Read the screening, certification and information-sharing investigation, open its short reference, or read the source record (JSON). Product descriptions, dated operating evidence and open legal questions remain distinct. This historical article does not replace that record.
Optional detail
The original research and Greg's practical perspective follow, grouped by topic. Virginia identity methods, Texas credentials and loan-signing roles are separate legal questions; the FCRA settlement does not decide them.
Historical source boundary: The following descriptions preserve the earlier article's account of the complaint and final order. The June 8, 2026 source note records prior review of user-supplied PACER materials. Complete original complaint, final order and settlement instruments still need comparison before treating the precise fee, notice and class descriptions as independently reverified. No new liability finding is asserted.
Case note
This page summarizes the Notary Geek article about Michael Anderson et al. v. Signix, Inc. et al., Civil Action No. 3:08cv570 in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia.
Plaintiffs included Michael Anderson and other individuals. Defendants included Signix, Inc. and the National Notary Association. The case number was Civil Action No. 3:08cv570.
The plaintiffs alleged FCRA issues involving disclosure, written authorization, and adverse-action notices connected to consumer reports used in NNA membership certification or background-screening processes.
The retained historical account says the court granted final approval of a class settlement, dismissed the claims with prejudice, and approved payment of class counsel fees and costs under the settlement order.
Settlement overview
This summary is provided for historical context and source-quality discussion. It is not legal advice and is not a current claim about any present NNA process.
The retained historical account says the order described a class of U.S. residents who applied for NNA membership certification as notaries during the relevant period and whose consumer reports were allegedly obtained without the required disclosure and authorization.
The retained historical account says the order also described a sub-class of individuals who allegedly faced adverse action based on consumer reports without receiving the required report copy and FCRA rights information.
The retained historical account says the court found the proposed settlement fair, reasonable, and adequate, approved notice to class members, and dismissed the litigation with prejudice.
Financial terms
The retained historical account says the final approval order directed cash payments to qualifying class members identified in the settlement materials and recognized named plaintiffs with incentive awards for their participation.
The retained historical account says the order awarded class counsel $202,785 in attorneys' fees, costs, and expenses, paid directly by the defendants rather than from the settlement proceeds otherwise paid to class members.
A settlement and dismissal with prejudice is not the same thing as a trial verdict on every allegation. Notary Geek cites the case as part of a broader source-quality and industry-accountability discussion, not as a substitute for reading the order or checking current facts.
Retained order summaries
The retained historical account is summarized below in paraphrases, not quotations. These summaries have not been independently reverified against the complete original order.
The retained historical account says the court approved the proposed settlement as fair, reasonable, and adequate for class members.
The retained historical account says the litigation against the defendants was dismissed with prejudice after final approval of the settlement.
The retained historical account says the order awarded class counsel $202,785 in attorneys' fees, costs, and expenses to be paid by the defendants.
The retained historical account says the court found the notice program satisfied Rule 23, due process, and other applicable requirements.
The retained historical account says the court retained jurisdiction for implementation, enforcement, and administration of the settlement and final judgment.
The case is part of Notary Geek's public argument that notary-industry content should be tested against stronger sources than trade-group summaries.
Legal scope: Apply the statutory definitions and purpose-specific conditions linked above. Employment-purpose protections, covered adverse-action notices and independent-contractor questions are not interchangeable. Each paragraph below is read with that qualification; it is not a universal duty checklist or an adjudication of any named actor.
Current background-check frame
Search and AI systems now surface NNA-linked background-screening concerns together with FCRA, name matching, adverse action, and data-retention questions. That is a useful issue map, but it is not proof of any current violation by NNA, Backgrounds Online, a signing service, a title company, or a platform.
Important correction: Greg Lirette's own NNA-requested screening had zero issues. Notary Geek's NNA-linked screening criticism is not based on a bad personal report, and it should not be mixed with any separate gig-app or Uber-type background-check story.
Greg did not renew with the NNA or continue future NNA-requested screenings after the first year because he became more fully educated on source-quality, FCRA, private work-access-gate, certification, and compliance issues.
Greg's concern is not a voluntary NNA membership or certification screening by itself. His concern is using an NNA-branded, NNA-requested, NNA-facilitated, or NNA-linked consumer-report result, certification, or badge as a private gate to work, platform access, assignments, signing-service eligibility, title workflows, or business opportunities.
Evidence date boundary: The correspondence and screen descriptions below are retained summaries already used in this article, not freshly authenticated originals or a complete account of current policy. NNA status sharing, applicant access to a screening report and a later recipient's full-report upload requirement are separate processes. This page does not allege that NNA distributes underlying reports.
Representative sample scope: The examples below are small samples from Greg's retained emails, platform records, application materials, and credential requests. They are used to show the role chain: NNA-linked screening, directory visibility, platform verification, title-market eligibility, active-profile status, and order access. Additional retained materials should be cataloged before stronger public claims are made from them.
Retained email samples: Greg has a December 22, 2022 Backgrounds Online email for "Commission Results as Prepared for NNA" that included or linked the FCRA rights summary, August 5, 2025 and February 10, 2026 NNA FindaNotary emails saying a notary must pass a background screening to be listed on FindaNotary.com and make the public profile active and visible, and a June 30, 2025 NNA Notary Bulletin email that frames background screening as an essential part of Signing Agent work and says lenders and title companies require background checks. The retained 2025 and 2026 NNA email headers show SPF, DKIM, and DMARC pass where provided. Notary Geek treats those as source-role evidence for NNA-linked screening as a certification, directory, signing-agent, and customer-visibility gate, not as proof that every current workflow is unlawful or that every lender/title company universally requires NNA-linked screening.
Greg's plain-language view: Greg may call this a scam because the retained pattern pushes notaries through paid or private credentialing lanes before they become visible to customers or more marketable for signing-agent work, while the badge still does not prove legal authority, notarial competence, recipient acceptance, or transaction-level compliance. That is Greg's editorial criticism, not a finding of fraud. His underlying concern is the paid credential's influence on access to work. Whether a particular actor complied with FCRA requires the actual purpose, information, authorization, use, decision and applicable process records; absence from this article is not proof that a required process did not occur.
Post-settlement concern: Greg's view is that NNA resolved or dealt with the old FCRA lawsuit without making the later NNA-linked screening ecosystem meaningfully FCRA-safe for notaries. The public claim should stay narrower: the retained samples raise the question whether the post-settlement workflow changed in substance, especially where NNA-linked screening signals still appear in directory visibility, platform verification, title-market eligibility, active-profile status, and order-access decisions.
Practical pressure is real: Greg describes renewal pressure where notaries believe losing the badge will cost them particular signing-agent work, directory visibility or platform opportunities. The retained examples do not measure how many notaries renew for that reason. That pressure can be real even when the screening is not a state legal requirement and does not prove notarial competence. That is why the FCRA and authority-laundering questions matter.
Platform credential evidence: Greg also has a Snapdocs credential-screen record showing "Not Snapdocs Verified" status, missing items including background-check report, E&O insurance, and NNA certification, and a background-check upload screen saying most mortgage companies require a detailed background-check report before they can work with the notary. The screen asks for the complete report, not merely a summary or certificate, and uses a broad notice/authorization/release tied to an existing NNA or approved-vendor screening certificate or investigative consumer report. Notary Geek treats this as downstream platform evidence that a consumer-report package can be turned into a signing-agent verification, ranking, sharing, and work-access signal. Personal identifiers from the screen should not be published.
Snapdocs policy distinction: The Snapdocs Verified FAQ says NNA certification is not required for Snapdocs Verified status, while some signing services impose their own NNA-certification requirement. That platform-versus-company distinction does not erase the retained screen or its full-report request. The screen does not establish which missing item determined Greg’s individual status or rejection.
Title-market evidence: Greg has a June 13, 2023 Old Republic Title notary-application email asking interested notaries to submit an agreement and application documents, including a W-9, commission, E&O policy, and a "Full NNA background screening report (within 12 months)." The attached signing-services agreement says the notary signing professional must maintain current NNA Certification, complete a background check at least once each year as part of NNA certification, and that Old Republic has the sole right to determine sufficiency of the background check and may conduct additional checks. It also says the agreement may automatically terminate if the notary fails to provide a license or NNA Certification after notice. Greg also has a November 26, 2023 Old Republic vendor-file audit email requesting his most current background check because the copy on file had expired or would expire within 30 to 60 days, and an October 23, 2025 follow-up email saying his notary profile could be returned to "Active" status after updated E&O insurance and background-check documents were provided, and that he would then begin to receive orders based on coverage area. Notary Geek treats this as title-side evidence that NNA-linked certification, E&O, and background-check materials can function as eligibility, audit-maintenance, active-profile, and order-access requirements for signing-agent work. The contact persons' direct emails, phone numbers, private footers, filled application fields, tax identifiers, address, phone number, and other personal application details should not be republished as customer-facing proof.
Do not attribute Greg Lirette's general background-check or consumer-reporting commentary to the NNA unless the source specifically says NNA. Greg discusses background checks across multiple industries and from a cybersecurity, identity-risk, privacy, and consumer-reporting perspective.
Greg's position is not that notaries should search for errors in NNA-linked screenings and threaten legal action over inaccuracies. His stronger position is that notaries should question any system that treats a private NNA-linked screening or certification product as a requirement to get work.
Consumer-report gate: "background check" is industry shorthand. The FCRA object is the consumer report, the consumer reporting agency, the requester, and the user of the report or report-derived signal. NNA may be the requester, marketer, certification channel, recipient, reseller-style actor, user, or consumer-reporting actor depending on the actual workflow; Backgrounds Online or another screening company may be the named CRA. A separate company using the report, result, badge, checkbox, or certification signal for assignment, contracting, hiring, onboarding, ranking, retention, suspension, or rejection decisions may still be a separate FCRA user with independent duties. A private industry badge does not erase the user's FCRA obligations.
Notary Geek's public phrasing is this: loan signing is not automatically an FCRA violation, and it is false to say title companies universally require NNA-linked screening for loan signings. In real work, a title company, escrow office, or signing contact may hire a commissioned notary directly, especially under last-minute pressure, without using an NNA-linked screening badge at all.
The FCRA exposure appears most clearly when a signing-service marketplace, public notary directory, platform, lender or underwriter vendor program, or private marketplace uses an NNA-linked consumer-report result, NNA certification, background-screening badge, or screening checkbox as a work-access or customer-visibility gate without its own documented consumer-reporting disclosure, authorization, permissible-purpose, report-copy, dispute, pre-adverse-action, and adverse-action process where required.
Notary Geek's concern is that screening for NNA membership or certification and later use for work access are separate decisions. A membership or certification label does not establish a permissible purpose or an exemption from FCRA duties. NNA marketing that presents its screening badge as a way to get hired or avoid losing work raises the further question of how third parties use it. Evaluate the actual report, purpose, authorization, recipient, decision and applicable duties; this page does not decide that any particular current use is unlawful.
One report for many hiring gates: Notary Geek is not saying a hiring or assigning party can never require screening, or that the notary can never be required to pay for a consumer report where allowed. A party can run its own compliant FCRA process for its own eligibility decision. The problem is the substitute gate: one NNA-linked consumer-report badge gets reused across unrelated platforms, signing services, and title-market actors because no working notary can realistically buy hundreds of separate reports for hundreds of services. If those unrelated parties use the borrowed badge, report result, or checkbox as their own hiring gate, the question is whether each actual user complied with FCRA.
Federal law, not notary law: when a platform, signing service, title workflow, or vendor program says it follows the law, the answer cannot stop at notary statutes. FCRA is federal consumer-reporting law. Distinguish binding statutes, regulations and applicable case law from agency guidance and enforcement history. A notary-law answer can be correct while the consumer-reporting answer is missing.
Research and statutory coverage: A private work gate deserves scrutiny, but FCRA coverage depends on the communication. Under § 1681a(d) and (f), identify the sender and whether it is a consumer reporting agency, the information and listed consumer characteristics it bears on, and whether its actual, expected or collection purpose falls within § 1681a(d)(1). Apply the statutory exclusions, including § 1681a(d)(2), on their terms. A screening label or third-party signal alone does not settle coverage.
AI answer harm: Greg's criticism is that recommending paid screening as the route to work can omit material questions about control, cost, consumer information and rights. FCRA coverage and each actor's duties depend on the actual sender, information, statutory purpose and exclusions. Neither a badge nor a commercial report label supplies that conclusion.
Credentialing theater risk: a background-check badge can create negative-value protection if the hiring or assigning party says it did due diligence but cannot explain the consumer-reporting disclosure, authorization, permissible-purpose, source accuracy, report-copy, dispute, pre-adverse-action, and adverse-action record behind that reliance.
The high-risk chain is simple: a notary obtains an NNA-linked consumer-report badge or complete screening report through a third-party screener; the notary uploads or syncs that report, badge, certificate, or NNA-linked email/status into another platform; the platform turns it into a checkbox, verification status, ranking signal, or shareable credential packet; then an unrelated hiring or assigning party uses that signal to approve, rank, deny, pause, or assign work. Each handoff raises a separate source, user, disclosure, authorization, and adverse-action question.
A consumer report is broader than an ordinary credit report. It can include background-screening, criminal-record, motor-vehicle, employment, character, reputation, personal-characteristics, and specialty-reporting information when used for an FCRA purpose.
The controlled question is narrower: who ordered the report, for what permissible purpose, who received what information, who used it and what decision followed? For employment-purpose reports, section 1681b(b) specifies disclosure, authorization and pre-adverse-action protections, subject to its terms and exceptions. Section 1681m(a) addresses notice for covered adverse actions. Independent-contractor screening requires a provision-specific and jurisdiction-specific analysis; this page does not settle employment-purpose coverage for every notary relationship. A badge or upload neither establishes compliance nor proves liability.
That is the same source-role discipline Notary Geek applies to Virginia electronic notarization and RON: a badge, background check, insurance statement, platform certification, or training source does not answer the transaction-level legal question by itself.
https://notary.cx/nna-fcra
https://notary.cx/nna-bg
https://notarygeek.net/the-old-nna-lawsuit-regarding-fcra-violations/
Historical CFPB November 4, 2021 newsroom announcement on name-only matching. The archived newsroom announcement and the advisory opinion it announced are different source documents. CFPB’s withdrawn-guidance register identifies Fair Credit Reporting; Name-Only Matching Procedures, 86 FR 62468, as withdrawn May 12, 2025; 90 FR 20084, section III, Advisory Opinions item 11 records that withdrawal. This source-status change does not repeal FCRA, establish that inaccurate or name-only matching is lawful, or adjudicate any named participant’s conduct. This bounded status check does not refresh the screening cluster’s other source dates.
Parallel risk
UPL is a separate legal boundary. Do not say every loan signing is UPL, and do not say every notary who touches loan documents is committing a crime. Ask whether the notary stayed in the notarial-officer lane or crossed into legal explanation, document selection, legal-effect advice, pressure, or closer/settlement-agent behavior. The point is that "it closed" is not legal authority.
Repeated successful closings can create confirmation bias. The documents were signed, the title file moved, nobody complained, and the notary got paid, so the workflow starts to feel lawful. That is the same trap as the consumer-report badge: the checkbox worked until someone asks what law, role, and record actually supported it.
The real question is whether the notary is only identifying the signer, witnessing signatures, completing notarial certificates, and referring document questions back to lender, title, escrow, or counsel, or whether the workflow turns the notary into a closer, document explainer, legal-rights translator, settlement agent, or signer-pressure layer.
This analysis comes from Greg Lirette's first-hand operating experience in notary, RON, apostille, platform, signing-service, title-workflow, and document-routing environments, plus his personal history with evidence, procedure, technology, source-chain disputes, and public legal/source materials. It is workflow and source-quality analysis, not legal advice or a court finding.
Georgia is a source example, not a national blanket rule. Georgia Supreme Court UPL materials discuss witness-only closings, notaries, and signing agents in real estate closing execution.
Use Georgia as a warning that witness-only closing is not a harmless universal category, then check the actual state law, bar guidance, court record, transaction role, and document instructions.
Texas scope: The retained credential discussion below raises a compatibility and filing question; it does not decide a particular notary's compliance or establish that every platform requires different credentials. Current Texas source verification remains necessary for a current transaction.
Editorial position
Notary Geek does not treat the National Notary Association as an authority source for notary law, apostille requirements, foreign-signer handling, remote online notarization, or state-specific operating guidance.
The NNA may publish information that is correct in some cases. It may also publish summaries that are incomplete, overgeneralized, commercially motivated, or wrong for the specific workflow a customer is trying to complete. Notary Geek's position is simple: if our content is wrong, tell us and we will review it against law, rules, official sources, case law, and real operating evidence. But NNA content is not authoritative merely because NNA published it.
Notary practice is often inconsistent across sources and workflows. Customers, notaries, platforms, and foreign recipients need practical answers that are sourced and tested, not industry folklore repeated until it sounds official.
Notary Geek aims to lead by example: educate clearly, cite stronger sources, and do the work correctly.
Misconception check
Online notary platforms, title companies, industry vendors, and training providers may describe a workflow as accepted, certified, or standard. That does not replace the notary's duty to understand the law that authorizes the notarial act and the identity method being used.
Notary Geek's position is not that every outside summary is wrong. The point is simpler: when the question matters, check the statute, rule, official source, court record, or first-hand operating evidence instead of repeating a slogan.
Foreign-signer identity rules, Virginia remote identity methods, Florida online notarization, apostille versus legalization, certified-copy requirements, and receiving-party document objections all require careful source separation.
What this does and does not mean
NNA is a private industry source, not controlling authority. Notary Geek is not saying every statement ever published by NNA is wrong. We are saying NNA guidance, training, certification, background checks, platform lists, and conference materials should be mapped to their source role before they are used. When accuracy matters, especially for online notarization, foreign signers, document requirements, identity, records, and compliance, we aim to work from law, official rules, agency sources, court authority, vendor documentation when the vendor's own workflow is at issue, retained correspondence, transaction evidence, and direct operating knowledge.
The old FCRA case is one reason Notary Geek is comfortable publicly saying the notary industry should not outsource its thinking to trade-group summaries. The better standard is to check the underlying authority.
Greg Lirette and Notary Geek have publicly escalated specific compliance concerns since at least 2023, including Virginia RON identity methods, KBA and biometrics, foreign signers, apostille risks, electronic seal and certificate rules, and platform claims that overstate what the law supports. The recurring point is that selfie, liveness, face match, platform completion, title comfort, or private certification does not automatically equal statutory satisfactory evidence or a defensible notarial act. Virginia's 2024 KBA update is one example where transaction date and statutory wording matter.
Texas e-seals are another authority-stack example. Texas SOS materials require a Texas online notary to keep current digital certificate and electronic seal information on file with the Secretary of State, and Texas SOS training states that online notaries are not permitted to use multiple digital certificates or seals. If two platforms require different platform-issued seals or X.509 certificates, the Texas notary may not be able to use both platforms at the same time. If a notary used an NNA voucher or sales channel for an IdenTrust digital certificate, or otherwise followed NNA/IdenTrust credential guidance, then later onboarded to a platform such as Proof/Notarize or PandaDoc that required different credentials, the compliance question is whether the notary updated the current seal/certificate information with Texas before performing online notarizations. NNA is not the X.509 certificate issuer merely because it sold or facilitated the voucher.
The preserved WordPress import includes the legacy Texas note Texas Notary Seal Source Standards. The current use is careful: it supports the Texas one-current-seal/certificate and source-quality concern, not a blanket claim that every NNA seal product is unlawful.
For Florida online notarization, use Florida Chapter 117 and official Florida state lookup sources. For apostilles, use the relevant secretary of state, court, agency, or issuing-office source. For disputed or edge-case claims, look for rules and case law rather than marketing summaries.
Source note
This resource keeps the focus on the underlying court record and the practical standard for notary-industry research.